These trees are autumn-color picks, not autumn-flowering trees: the three options supplied are valued for fall foliage, and none is described as producing autumn blossoms. I rank the Brandywine maple first for its defined mature size, cold hardiness, and red-purple display; the Autumn Blaze maple for faster growth and a broader mix of fall colors; and the Autumn Gold ginkgo for buyers who want golden leaves instead of maple reds. The main tradeoffs are mature footprint, the time and water needed to establish a young tree, and whether your site gets full sun. I would check local planting conditions and shipping eligibility before choosing, since restrictions differ by tree.
Get garden gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Best balanced choice: Brandywine maple is listed at 25–35 feet tall and 15–25 feet wide, a more manageable mature footprint than either other option.
- Best for quick shade: Autumn Blaze is described as fast-growing and reaches 40–50 feet tall, but its 30–40-foot spread needs substantial room.
- Best golden fall color: Autumn Gold ginkgo offers a yellow autumn display, unlike the red-purple Brandywine and the orange-red-yellow Autumn Blaze.
- Sun is a shared requirement: all three listings specify full sun, so none is the right pick for a persistently shaded planting site.
- Check delivery limits: Brandywine cannot ship to California or Arizona; Autumn Blaze excludes California, Arizona, Alaska, and Hawaii; Autumn Gold excludes Alaska, Arizona, Hawaii, and Oregon.
| Perfect Plants Brandywine Maple Tree, 4–5 ft |  | Best Overall — a red-purple maple with a comparatively restrained listed mature size | Botanical name: Acer rubrum ‘Brandywine’ | Plant type: Live tree | Item height: 4–5 ft | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Autumn Blaze Maple Tree, 1-Gallon Nursery Pot |  | Best for Faster Shade — a larger-growing maple with a multicolor fall display | Plant type: Deciduous tree | Pot size: 1 gallon | Mature height: 40–50 ft | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Brighter Blooms Autumn Gold Ginkgo Tree, 4–5 ft. |  | Best Golden Foliage — a color-focused alternative to the two red-toned maples | Plant type: Outdoor ginkgo tree | Height: 4–5 ft | Sunlight exposure: Full sun | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| autumn-flowering tree | Plant type | Mature height | USDA hardiness zones |
|---|---|---|---|
| Perfect Plants Brandywine Mapl | Live tree | 25–35 ft | 4–8 |
| Autumn Blaze Maple Tree | Deciduous tree | 40–50 ft | 3–8 |
| Brighter Blooms Autumn Gold Gi | Outdoor ginkgo tree | — | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Perfect Plants Brandywine Maple Tree, 4–5 ft
Best Overall — a red-purple maple with a comparatively restrained listed mature size
View Latest PriceThe Brandywine is my best overall pick because it combines a recognizable fall-color payoff with a stated mature footprint that is easier to place than the other two trees in this lineup. Its green spring and summer foliage turns red-purple in autumn, while a mature size of about 25–35 feet tall and 15–25 feet wide gives buyers more room to work with than the 40–50-foot Autumn Blaze. That does not make it a small tree, but it is the most size-conscious maple choice here.
Its other useful difference is the male selection: the listing says it does not produce numerous seedlings. That can appeal to people who want a maple without frequent seedling cleanup, though it does not make the tree maintenance-free. It is hardy in USDA Zones 4–8 and tolerates cold weather, but unlike Autumn Blaze, it is not listed for Zone 3. The product also calls for full sun and moderate soil moisture, so I would not choose it for a deeply shaded or consistently dry site.
Compared with Autumn Gold, Brandywine offers a red-purple rather than golden display and comes with clearer mature dimensions. Compared with Autumn Blaze, it is the more measured choice for a yard where a 30–40-foot spread would be difficult to accommodate. The tradeoff is that the listing specifies loam and moderate moisture, and the plant is a 4–5-foot live tree with a short 15-day manufacturer warranty. Buyers in California and Arizona cannot order this item according to the supplied details. I would favor it when the site has full sun, suitable room, and a preference for red-toned foliage over gold.
Pros:- Vivid red-purple fall foliage provides a distinct color choice beside the other two trees.
- Listed mature dimensions of 25–35 feet tall and 15–25 feet wide are more contained than Autumn Blaze.
- Cold tolerant and listed for USDA Zones 4–8.
- Male selection is described as producing no numerous seedlings.
Cons:- Requires full sun and moderate soil moisture.
- Unavailable for shipping to California and Arizona.
- The 15-day manufacturer warranty is limited, and the supplied size is only 4–5 feet.
Best for: Homeowners with a sunny site who want red-purple fall color, a defined medium-to-large mature footprint, and fewer numerous seedlings.
Not ideal for: Buyers in California or Arizona, gardeners without full sun, and anyone who needs a tree suited to USDA Zone 3 or a small planting area.
- Botanical name:Acer rubrum ‘Brandywine’
- Plant type:Live tree
- Item height:4–5 ft
- Mature height:25–35 ft
- Mature width:15–25 ft
- Sun exposure:Full sun
- USDA hardiness zones:4–8
- Soil and moisture:Loam; moderate moisture
- Shipping restriction:Cannot ship to California or Arizona
Our verdict“I would choose Brandywine for a sunny yard that can accommodate a medium-to-large tree but benefits from a more contained footprint than Autumn Blaze.”
Autumn Blaze Maple Tree, 1-Gallon Nursery Pot
Autumn Blaze stands out for buyers who want a tree described as fast-growing and are prepared for a substantial canopy. Its foliage can show orange, red, and yellow in fall, offering a broader color mix than Brandywine’s red-purple or Autumn Gold’s single golden-yellow emphasis. The rounded canopy is intended to provide shade, and the tree is listed for USDA Zones 3–8, the broadest hardiness range of the three.
That growth potential comes with a real space commitment: the listed mature height is 40–50 feet and spread is 30–40 feet. It is a more demanding fit than Brandywine, whose stated mature dimensions are notably smaller. Before buying, I would measure the planting area against the mature spread rather than judging by the one-gallon nursery pot. The young size may be easier to handle initially, but it does not signal a compact adult tree.
Autumn Blaze also has the clearest establishment guidance in the lineup: it needs regular watering while getting established, then is described as moderately drought-tolerant. It prefers full sun and moist, well-drained, acidic soil. This makes it a stronger fit for a buyer willing to water and plan around a large canopy than for someone seeking a low-input tree or a restrained ornamental. The listing says no blossoms, so this is a fall-foliage selection, not an autumn-flowering tree. Shipping is unavailable to California, Arizona, Alaska, and Hawaii. Compared with the ginkgo, it offers a wider palette and more explicit size information; compared with Brandywine, it prioritizes growth and scale over a smaller footprint.
Pros:- Fast-growing habit and rounded canopy are suited to buyers seeking shade.
- Fall foliage can combine orange, red, and yellow rather than one dominant color.
- Hardy in USDA Zones 3–8, including colder areas beyond Brandywine’s listed range.
- Moderately drought-tolerant once established, though regular early watering is needed.
Cons:- A mature spread of 30–40 feet requires more room than Brandywine.
- Needs regular watering during establishment and moist, well-drained soil.
- No blossoms are expected, and shipping excludes California, Arizona, Alaska, and Hawaii.
Best for: Buyers with generous planting space who want a fast-growing shade tree, a mix of orange, red, and yellow fall foliage, and hardiness down to Zone 3.
Not ideal for: People with small yards, shaded sites, or limited ability to water during establishment; also unsuitable for listed shipping-excluded states.
- Plant type:Deciduous tree
- Pot size:1 gallon
- Mature height:40–50 ft
- Mature spread:30–40 ft
- USDA hardiness zones:3–8
- Sunlight:Full sun
- Soil:Acidic, moist, well-drained
- Watering:Regular while establishing; moderately drought-tolerant once established
- Expected bloom:No blossoms
Our verdict“I would pick Autumn Blaze when faster shade and a broad fall palette matter more than keeping the mature canopy compact.”
Brighter Blooms Autumn Gold Ginkgo Tree, 4–5 ft.
Autumn Gold is the clearest choice for someone who wants golden-yellow autumn foliage rather than a red or multicolor maple display. The listing describes green foliage that provides seasonal shade before turning brilliant yellow. That makes it a strong visual alternative to Brandywine’s red-purple leaves and Autumn Blaze’s orange-red-yellow mix. It is supplied at 4–5 feet, the same stated starting height as Brandywine, and is described as hardy and low maintenance.
The biggest limitation for comparison shopping is missing information. Unlike both maples, this listing does not provide a mature height, mature spread, or USDA hardiness-zone range. It also gives a spring expected blooming period, not an autumn bloom period; the promised autumn feature is foliage color. I would seek the seller’s planting and mature-size guidance before choosing it for a site where overhead clearance or nearby structures matter. Its deer-resistant feature may be useful where browsing is a concern, but the available description does not quantify how well it performs under local conditions.
Autumn Gold is described as thriving in various soil conditions and climates, yet it still lists full sun as its exposure. That shared requirement puts it in the same category as both maples: a poor match for a shady location. Compared with Autumn Blaze, the ginkgo has a simpler gold-only color story and no supplied fast-growth claim; compared with Brandywine, it gives less detail for planning the mature footprint and cold tolerance. Shipping is restricted from Alaska, Arizona, Hawaii, and Oregon. I would choose it for the distinct yellow display only after confirming its mature size and suitability for the planting site.
Pros:- Brilliant golden-yellow fall foliage offers a clear alternative to the maples’ red and orange tones.
- Green seasonal foliage is described as providing shade.
- Listed as deer resistant, hardy, and low maintenance.
- Supplied at 4–5 feet, matching Brandywine’s stated starting height.
Cons:- No mature height, mature spread, or USDA hardiness-zone range is supplied.
- Requires full sun despite the broad claims about climate and soil flexibility.
- Shipping excludes Alaska, Arizona, Hawaii, and Oregon.
Best for: Gardeners who specifically want golden-yellow autumn leaves, value the listed deer-resistant feature, and can confirm local hardiness and mature-size details before planting.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need published mature dimensions or a USDA zone range, anyone with a shaded site, and residents of listed shipping-restricted states.
- Plant type:Outdoor ginkgo tree
- Height:4–5 ft
- Sunlight exposure:Full sun
- Expected blooming period:Spring
- Special feature:Deer resistant
- Description of autumn color:Golden-yellow foliage
- Planting period:Spring
- Shipping restrictions:Cannot ship to Alaska, Arizona, Hawaii, or Oregon
Our verdict“I would select Autumn Gold for its distinctive yellow fall display, but only after getting the mature-size and local-hardiness details missing from the listing.”
How We Picked
I compared these three listings against the promise of an autumn tree: each needs a clear fall-foliage appeal, but a useful shortlist also has to distinguish the trees by color, scale, hardiness, and care demands. The supplied product details describe fall foliage rather than autumn blooms, so I treat them as autumn-color trees rather than suggesting that any one flowers in fall. Autumn Blaze explicitly lists no blossoms, while the other two descriptions focus on seasonal leaf color as well.
My ranking gives weight to how readily a buyer can match a tree to a real site. I put Brandywine first because its stated mature size is smaller than the other maples here, its zones span 4–8, and its male selection is described as producing no numerous seedlings. Autumn Blaze ranks next for its fast growth, wider range of fall colors, and zones 3–8, though its eventual size and establishment watering call for planning. Autumn Gold makes the shortlist for a distinct golden-yellow display and a deer-resistant feature, but the supplied information gives no mature dimensions or hardiness-zone range, making site planning less specific.
I also account for the shared full-sun requirement and the shipping restrictions listed for each seller. Those details can eliminate a choice before color preferences matter. I do not infer unlisted traits such as exact growth rates for Brandywine or ginkgo, bloom timing beyond the supplied fields, or local performance. Nursery stock can vary, so buyers should confirm plant condition, local suitability, and planting guidance with the seller or a regional horticulture resource.
| autumn-flowering tree | Plant type |
|---|---|
| Perfect Plants Brandywine Mapl | Live tree |
| Autumn Blaze Maple Tree | Deciduous tree |
| Brighter Blooms Autumn Gold Gi | Outdoor ginkgo tree |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Autumn-flowering Trees
For these three trees, choosing by autumn color is only the starting point. I would match the foliage you want to the tree’s eventual size, sun exposure, local hardiness, and establishment needs. The listings describe leaf color rather than fall blossoms, so buyers searching for flowers that open in autumn should look for a different group of plants.
Choose the fall color before the tree
Brandywine is the focused choice for red-purple foliage. Autumn Blaze gives a more varied orange, red, and yellow mix, while Autumn Gold centers on a brilliant golden-yellow display. Think about how those colors will sit beside existing trees, buildings, and evergreen plantings. If you want a red-toned centerpiece, Brandywine is the most direct match. If you prefer varied warm shades and also want a tree described as fast-growing, Autumn Blaze has the stronger fit. For a clear yellow feature, the ginkgo stands apart. None of the three supplied descriptions promises autumn flowers; Autumn Blaze explicitly lists no blossoms, and Autumn Gold’s expected blooming period is spring.
Plan around mature dimensions
Do not let the nursery size obscure the eventual footprint. Brandywine is listed at 25–35 feet tall and 15–25 feet wide, while Autumn Blaze can reach 40–50 feet tall and 30–40 feet wide. That difference can decide the purchase if your yard has nearby buildings, utility lines, a narrow lawn, or competing plantings. Autumn Gold is supplied at 4–5 feet, but its listing does not state mature dimensions. I would ask for that information rather than assuming a young ginkgo will remain small. Use the mature spread when judging clearance, not the width of the pot or the tree at delivery.
Match sunlight and moisture to the site
All three listings call for full sun, so a site that stays shaded for much of the day is a weak match for this shortlist. Their moisture details differ. Brandywine lists loam and moderate moisture. Autumn Blaze specifies acidic, moist, well-drained soil and regular watering during establishment, with moderate drought tolerance once established. Autumn Gold is described as suitable for varied soils, but the listing gives little detail about watering. Where summer conditions are dry, make sure you can provide establishment water and ask a local nursery how the species performs in your soil. A general claim of low maintenance does not remove the need to water a newly planted tree.
Check hardiness information and shipping limits
Autumn Blaze has the broadest supplied zone range at USDA Zones 3–8; Brandywine is listed for Zones 4–8. The Autumn Gold listing does not give a zone range, so I would verify local winter suitability before ordering rather than treating the broad phrase “various climates” as a substitute. Shipping eligibility also varies: Brandywine excludes California and Arizona; Autumn Blaze excludes California, Arizona, Alaska, and Hawaii; Autumn Gold excludes Alaska, Arizona, Hawaii, and Oregon. These are seller restrictions, and they do not establish whether a tree would thrive in every state where delivery is available.
Treat autumn color and autumn flowers as different goals
The title phrase “autumn-flowering” can suggest blossoms appearing in fall, but the supplied products are selected for autumn leaf color. Brandywine turns red-purple, Autumn Blaze develops orange, red, and yellow foliage, and Autumn Gold turns yellow. Autumn Gold’s product details list spring as its expected blooming period; Autumn Blaze says it has no blossoms. If you specifically need a tree that flowers in autumn, these three listings do not establish that any option meets that requirement. Search for a species with a documented fall flowering season and check its hardiness and mature size before buying.
Account for what the listings do not tell you
A product page can help narrow color and starting size, but it may leave practical questions unanswered. Autumn Gold lacks mature dimensions and a hardiness range; all three need full sun; and the Brandywine listing gives a 15-day manufacturer warranty. Before ordering, review the seller’s current plant-care instructions, delivery and return terms, and any regional planting advice. Consider the tree’s mature canopy and root space, and check local rules or utility guidance where relevant. This is especially useful for Autumn Blaze, whose listed adult spread is the largest, and for Autumn Gold, whose mature size is not stated in the supplied details.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do any of these trees flower in autumn?
The supplied details support choosing them for autumn foliage color, not autumn blossoms. Brandywine is described for red-purple fall leaves, Autumn Blaze for orange, red, and yellow leaves and explicitly no blossoms, and Autumn Gold for golden-yellow leaves. Autumn Gold lists spring as its expected blooming period. If fall flowers are your priority, these products do not establish that they meet it.
Which tree has the most compact listed mature size?
Brandywine has the smallest stated mature footprint among the trees with dimensions supplied: about 25–35 feet tall and 15–25 feet wide. Autumn Blaze is listed at 40–50 feet tall and 30–40 feet wide. Autumn Gold may or may not be smaller, but the supplied listing gives no mature dimensions, so I would not assume it is compact without checking with the seller.
Which option is listed for the coldest hardiness zone?
Autumn Blaze has the lowest listed zone number, with a range of USDA Zones 3–8; Brandywine is listed for Zones 4–8. The Autumn Gold description calls it hardy but supplies no zone range. If you garden in a colder location, Autumn Blaze has the clearest listing support of the three, though local conditions and seller guidance still matter.
Which tree should I choose for golden-yellow fall color?
Autumn Gold is the most direct match if you want a golden-yellow autumn display. Brandywine is the better fit for red-purple leaves, while Autumn Blaze offers orange, red, and yellow. Before choosing the ginkgo, confirm mature size and local hardiness because those details are not included in the supplied listing.
Can I plant one of these trees in a partly shaded yard?
All three product listings specify full sun, so none is the strongest choice for a persistently shaded site. If your yard receives only partial sunlight, ask a local horticulture expert whether the exposure is likely to support the specific tree and the fall display you want. Do not assume that the trees’ different colors or hardiness ranges change their stated sun requirement.
Conclusion
For the most straightforward balance of autumn color and stated mature size, I would choose Brandywine, provided the site is sunny, in Zones 4–8, and outside its shipping-excluded states. I would pick Autumn Blaze for a spacious yard where faster growth, a broad warm-color display, and Zone 3 hardiness matter more than keeping the canopy modest. Choose Autumn Gold if yellow leaves are the main goal and you are willing to confirm its mature dimensions and local hardiness before ordering. If what you actually need is a tree that flowers in fall rather than one with colorful fall leaves, I would skip all three and search for a product with documented autumn blooms.
