The best bird seed for squirrels depends on whether you want a simple treat, a large-volume feed, or a mix for several kinds of wildlife. My best overall pick is Pennington Classic Shelled Peanuts for a straightforward, squirrel-friendly ingredient, while Audubon Park Squirrel & Critter Food stands out as a purpose-made option and CountryMax Cracked Corn suits buyers who need a large supply. The main tradeoff is between focused ingredients that make feeding choices simple and mixed feeds that offer more variety but may attract a broader range of visitors. Bag size also affects storage and how quickly you can use the feed while it stays fresh. Read on for the full breakdown and help matching each option to your yard.
Get garden gear delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Simple peanut feeds are the most focused choices: Pennington’s shelled peanuts suit buyers who want one recognizable ingredient, while the raw in-shell option adds shells and a different feeding format.
- Purpose-made wildlife blends offer broader appeal: Audubon Park and Kaytee Ultimate Backyard Wildlife Food are framed for squirrels and other critters, unlike bird-oriented mixes that may draw a wider variety of visitors.
- Large bags change the value equation: CountryMax’s 50-pound bag and Ernst’s 46-pound bag make the most sense when storage is available and feed will be used regularly.
- Mixes trade simplicity for variety: Lyric’s corn, nuts, and sunflower mix and the fruit-and-nut options offer more ingredient variety, but buyers should expect more kinds of wildlife to show interest.
- Match the feed format to your routine: Shelled peanuts are simpler to handle than in-shell peanuts, while small bags such as Kaytee Nut & Fruit are easier to try before committing to bulk quantities.
| Pennington Classic Shelled Peanuts for Birds and Wildlife, 5 lb |  | Best for High-Energy Squirrel Treats | Brand: Pennington | Product form: Shelled peanut pieces | Weight: 5 pounds | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| CountryMax Cracked Corn Feed, 50 lb |  | Best Bulk Value for Shared Wildlife Feeding | Weight: 50 pounds | Form: Cracked corn | Target animals: Chickens, turkeys, birds, deer, squirrels, and other wildlife | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Lyric Wild Bird Mix with Corn, Nuts, and Sunflower Seeds, 40 lb |  | Best for Bird Feeders That Also Welcome Squirrels | Weight: 40 lb | Ingredients: Cracked corn, white proso millet, shelled peanuts, safflower seeds, black striped sunflower seeds, black oil sunflower seeds | Sunflower seed content: Over 20% | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Kaytee Nut & Fruit Wild Bird Seed, 5 lb |  | Best Small-Bag Bird Mix for Occasional Squirrel Visitors | Brand: Kaytee | Weight: 5 lb | Form: Chunk | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Sommer’s Critter Snack Wildlife Feed, 20 lb |  | Best Dedicated Blend for Backyard Critters | Brand: Sommer’s Wild Bird Food | Weight: 20 lb | Ingredients: Corn, sunflower seeds, peanuts | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Audubon Park Squirrel & Critter Food, 15-lb Bag |  | Best Overall for Redirecting Squirrels | Brand: Audubon Park | Weight: 15 pounds | Ingredients: Corn, sunflower seed, peanuts | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Kaytee Ultimate Backyard Wildlife Food for Squirrels, Rabbits, and Chipmunks, 8 lb |  | Best for Beginners | Brand: Kaytee | Weight: 8 pounds | Form: Chunk | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Ernst Grain & Livestock Non-GMO Bird and Wildlife Feed, 46 lb |  | Best Bulk Wildlife Feed | Brand: Ernst Grain & Livestock | Weight: 46 pounds | Ingredients: Corn, barley, wheat, roasted soybeans, black oil sunflower seeds | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Lyric Fruit and Nut Wild Bird Seed Mix, 10 lb (2-Pack) |  | Best for Bird-First Yards | Brand: Lyric | Total weight: 10 pounds | Packaging: Two 5-pound bags | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| 15 lb Raw In-Shell Peanuts for Squirrels, Birds & Wildlife – Grown in the USA |  | Best Single-Ingredient Peanut Pick | Weight: 15 pounds | Food: Raw in-shell peanuts | Processing: Unroasted and unsalted | VIEW LATEST PRICE | See Our Full Breakdown |
| bird seed for squirrel | Weight | Brand | Form | Target animals |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pennington Classic Shelled Pea | 5 pounds | Pennington | — | — |
| CountryMax Cracked Corn Feed | 50 pounds | — | Cracked corn | Chickens, turkeys, birds, deer, squirrels, and other wildlife |
| Lyric Wild Bird Mix with Corn | 40 lb | — | — | — |
| Kaytee Nut & Fruit Wild Bird S | 5 lb | Kaytee | Chunk | — |
| Sommer’s Critter Snack Wildlif | 20 lb | Sommer’s Wild Bird Food | — | Squirrels, chipmunks, rabbits, birds, and other critters |
| Audubon Park Squirrel & Critte | 15 pounds | Audubon Park | Seed | — |
| Kaytee Ultimate Backyard Wildl | 8 pounds | Kaytee | Chunk | Squirrels, rabbits, chipmunks, and other backyard wildlife |
| Ernst Grain & Livestock Non-GM | 46 pounds | Ernst Grain & Livestock | Granule | Birds, ducks, squirrels, turkeys, rabbits, geese, deer |
| Lyric Fruit and Nut Wild Bird | — | Lyric | Nuts, seeds, and fruit | — |
| 15 lb Raw In-Shell Peanuts for | 15 pounds | — | — | Squirrels, birds, and other wildlife |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Pennington Classic Shelled Peanuts for Birds and Wildlife, 5 lb
Shelled peanuts make this a direct, energy-dense choice for buyers who want to feed squirrels without asking them to crack whole nuts. The product description highlights fat and protein, and the pieces can be scattered on the ground, where squirrels can reach them easily. Compared with CountryMax Cracked Corn Feed, this is a more concentrated peanut-based option rather than a large, general-purpose grain feed; it also comes in a much smaller bag. That smaller quantity suits occasional feeding, but it may not stretch far for a busy wildlife spot. The tradeoff is ingredient sensitivity: peanuts may not suit peanut-sensitive animals, and feeding them can draw birds and other wildlife alongside squirrels. I’d choose it for a focused treat, not as a sole diet.
Pros:- Shelled pieces are ready to scatter without requiring animals to crack shells.
- High-energy fat and protein suit use as a calorie-dense wildlife treat.
- Can attract woodpeckers, blue jays, squirrels, and other wildlife.
- The 5-pound bag is manageable for occasional feeding.
Cons:- Peanuts may be unsuitable around peanut-sensitive animals.
- A 5-pound bag may run out quickly at a frequently visited feeding area.
- Attracting several kinds of wildlife may make it harder to feed squirrels alone.
Best for: Squirrel keepers who want a small, ground-feedable supply of high-energy shelled peanuts for occasional outdoor feeding.
Not ideal for: Buyers feeding peanut-sensitive animals or looking for a large-volume, lower-specificity grain feed.
- Brand:Pennington
- Product form:Shelled peanut pieces
- Weight:5 pounds
- Package quantity:1
- Target species:Birds and other wildlife
- Diet type:Plant-based
- Life stage:All life stages
- Use:Outdoor wildlife feeding
Our verdict“Choose Pennington for convenient, peanut-based squirrel treats in a modest quantity, but skip it if peanuts are a concern.”
CountryMax Cracked Corn Feed, 50 lb
For buyers feeding a steady stream of backyard visitors, the 50-pound bag is the main reason to choose CountryMax. Its cracked corn can be scattered on the ground or put in a feeder, giving squirrels and birds access without the peanut-specific focus of Pennington Classic Shelled Peanuts. It is also listed for chickens, turkeys, deer, and other wildlife, so it suits a shared feeding area rather than a squirrel-only setup. Compared with Sommer’s Critter Snack Wildlife Feed, this is a simpler single-ingredient grain, while Sommer’s combines corn with sunflower seeds and peanuts. The tradeoff is that corn is supplemental feed, not a complete diet, and ground scattering may bring a wider mix of animals. I’d pick it for volume and flexibility, not ingredient variety.
Pros:- The 50-pound bag supports frequent feeding with fewer restocks.
- Cracked corn can be scattered or used in feeders.
- Suitable for several kinds of birds, livestock, and wildlife.
- Listed as made in the USA.
Cons:- It is supplemental feed rather than a complete diet.
- Ground feeding may attract many kinds of wildlife, not only squirrels.
- A 50-pound bag may be cumbersome for occasional or small-scale feeders.
Best for: Rural or high-traffic backyard feeders who need a large supply of ground-feedable corn for squirrels, birds, and other wildlife.
Not ideal for: Small-space feeders who want to limit wildlife visitors, or buyers seeking a varied blend or complete diet.
- Weight:50 pounds
- Form:Cracked corn
- Target animals:Chickens, turkeys, birds, deer, squirrels, and other wildlife
- Feeding method:Scatter on ground or use in feeders
- Suitable for:All life stages
- Origin:USA
Our verdict“Choose CountryMax when bulk corn for a mixed wildlife feeding area matters more than variety or squirrel-specific targeting.”
Lyric Wild Bird Mix with Corn, Nuts, and Sunflower Seeds, 40 lb
Feeder flexibility sets this 40-pound mix apart: it is listed for tube, hopper, tray, and window feeders, and its ingredients include corn, millet, peanuts, safflower, and striped and black oil sunflower seeds. With sunflower seeds making up over 20% of the blend, it is designed to draw a broad range of birds while still offering ingredients squirrels may eat. Compared with CountryMax Cracked Corn Feed, Lyric gives buyers more seed variety and more feeder options, but it is less straightforward as a bulk, squirrel-focused ground feed. The listed peanut allergen notice also matters for households with sensitive animals. I’d choose it when the goal is a mixed bird-and-squirrel feeding area, not when the priority is feeding squirrels with a simple, single-ingredient staple.
Pros:- Includes cracked corn, millet, peanuts, safflower, and two types of sunflower seed.
- Over 20% sunflower seed supports a bird-focused blend with broad appeal.
- Compatible with tube, hopper, tray, and window feeders.
- The 40-pound bag suits regular feeding.
Cons:- Peanuts may be an allergen concern for sensitive animals.
- The bird-oriented mix is less targeted to squirrels than dedicated wildlife feed.
- The large bag may be more than occasional feeders need.
Best for: Backyard birders who want a varied seed blend in several feeder styles and are comfortable sharing the feeding area with squirrels.
Not ideal for: Buyers focused mainly on inexpensive bulk ground feeding or avoiding peanuts in a wildlife mix.
- Weight:40 lb
- Ingredients:Cracked corn, white proso millet, shelled peanuts, safflower seeds, black striped sunflower seeds, black oil sunflower seeds
- Sunflower seed content:Over 20%
- Feeder compatibility:Tube, hopper, tray, and window feeders
- Target birds:Blue jays, doves, chickadees, cardinals, woodpeckers, nuthatches, finches, wrens, and more
- Allergen information:Peanuts may contain
Our verdict“Pick Lyric for a varied, multi-feeder bird mix that squirrels may also visit, rather than as a dedicated squirrel ration.”
Kaytee Nut & Fruit Wild Bird Seed, 5 lb
Nuts, sunflower seeds, and fruit give this compact blend a different role from the corn-heavy options: it is primarily made to attract songbirds, though squirrels may also be drawn to its calorie-rich ingredients. The 5-pound size suits a smaller feeder or a household that wants to try a varied blend without storing a large bag. Compared with Lyric Wild Bird Mix with Corn, Nuts, and Sunflower Seeds, Kaytee adds raisins and cherries but is described more narrowly around backyard songbirds, rather than a long list of feeder types. That makes it less suited to bulk squirrel feeding than CountryMax or Sommer’s Critter Snack. The tradeoff is a bird-first recipe and no stated squirrel-specific formulation; I’d treat squirrel visits as a likely side effect, not the reason to buy it.
Pros:- Combines sunflower seeds, peanuts, mixed nuts, raisins, cherries, and other seeds.
- Designed to attract several songbird types, including cardinals and woodpeckers.
- The 5-pound bag is manageable for small feeders or occasional use.
- Suitable for outdoor backyard bird feeding.
Cons:- It is intended for wild birds rather than as a dedicated squirrel feed.
- The small bag may not last long at a busy feeding station.
- Peanuts may be unsuitable around peanut-sensitive animals.
Best for: Bird-focused households with a small backyard feeder that want a fruit-and-nut blend and do not mind occasional squirrel visits.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a dedicated squirrel feed, a large-volume supply, or food for use as general-purpose pet feed.
- Brand:Kaytee
- Weight:5 lb
- Form:Chunk
- Flavor:Cherry
- Target species:Wild birds
- Recommended use:Backyard bird feeding
- Key ingredients:Sunflower seeds, peanuts, mixed nuts, raisins, cherries, and seeds
- Life stage:All life stages
- Model number:100061951
Our verdict“Choose Kaytee for a small, fruit-and-nut bird blend if squirrels are visitors rather than your primary feeding target.”
Sommer’s Critter Snack Wildlife Feed, 20 lb
Built around mixed wildlife feeding, Sommer’s combines corn, sunflower seeds, and peanuts for squirrels, chipmunks, rabbits, birds, and other backyard visitors. Its 20-pound size sits between Pennington’s 5-pound peanut pieces and CountryMax’s 50-pound corn bag, making it a middle-ground choice for ongoing feeding without committing to the largest quantity. It can go on the ground or in platform feeders, so buyers can set up a separate feeding spot away from bird feeders. Compared with Kaytee Nut & Fruit Wild Bird Seed, this is more explicitly aimed at squirrels and other critters, while Kaytee is framed as songbird food. The downside is limited nutritional detail and the possibility of attracting more wildlife to the area. I’d choose it for a shared critter station, not for buyers who want precise nutrition data.
Pros:- Formulated for squirrels, chipmunks, rabbits, birds, and other backyard wildlife.
- Mixes corn, sunflower seeds, and peanuts rather than relying on one feed ingredient.
- Can be offered on the ground or in a platform feeder.
- The 20-pound bag offers more volume than small treat bags without the scale of a 50-pound sack.
Cons:- No detailed nutritional analysis is provided.
- Feeding it may attract additional wildlife to the area.
- Contains peanuts, which may not suit peanut-sensitive animals.
Best for: Backyard wildlife enthusiasts who want a mid-size corn, sunflower, and peanut blend for ground or platform feeding.
Not ideal for: Buyers who need a detailed nutritional analysis, want to avoid peanuts, or want to attract only squirrels.
- Brand:Sommer’s Wild Bird Food
- Weight:20 lb
- Ingredients:Corn, sunflower seeds, peanuts
- Diet type:Plant-based
- Target animals:Squirrels, chipmunks, rabbits, birds, and other critters
- Recommended use:Wildlife feeding, ground feeding, platform feeders
Our verdict“Choose Sommer’s for a clearly wildlife-oriented, mid-size blend, but skip it if detailed nutrition or squirrel-only feeding is the priority.”
Audubon Park Squirrel & Critter Food, 15-lb Bag
Corn, sunflower seeds, and peanuts give this blend broad appeal to squirrels and several other backyard visitors, making it a practical choice when the goal is to offer wildlife an alternative to raiding bird feeders. I rank it ahead of Kaytee Ultimate Backyard Wildlife Food because its listed ingredients give buyers a clearer idea of what they are putting out. It also works in squirrel, platform, and table feeders, or scattered on the ground, so it fits yards without a dedicated feeder.
The 15-pound bag suits regular feeding better than a smaller trial-size supply, but the variety it attracts can also bring more animal traffic than some yards can accommodate. Peanuts are a concern for households managing food allergies, and this is a wildlife feed rather than a bird-focused seed mix. Choose it to redirect squirrels; skip it if your priority is feeding birds without inviting additional critters.
Pros:- Corn, sunflower seeds, and peanuts provide a specified mix that appeals to several kinds of backyard wildlife.
- Can be placed in squirrel, platform, or table feeders, or scattered on the ground.
- Designed to give squirrels an alternative to visiting bird feeders.
- 15-pound bag suits regular feeding routines.
Cons:- May attract more wildlife and increase animal activity around the yard.
- Peanuts and other potential allergens listed on the package may not suit every household.
- Not a bird-focused mix, so it may be a poor fit for buyers seeking seed chiefly for songbirds.
Best for: Backyard birders who want a clearly listed, multi-ingredient feed to redirect squirrels and other small wildlife from bird feeders.
Not ideal for: Households avoiding peanut or other listed potential allergens, and yards where attracting additional wildlife would be a nuisance.
- Brand:Audubon Park
- Weight:15 pounds
- Ingredients:Corn, sunflower seed, peanuts
- Form:Seed
- Container:Bag
- Life stage:All life stages
- Feeding options:Squirrel, platform, or table feeder; ground scattering
- Potential allergens:Fish, peanuts, soy, tree nuts, wheat
Our verdict“Choose this if you want a versatile, ingredient-listed blend for drawing squirrels away from bird feeders, but avoid it if extra wildlife or peanut allergens are a concern.”
Kaytee Ultimate Backyard Wildlife Food for Squirrels, Rabbits, and Chipmunks, 8 lb
For someone setting up a separate wildlife feeding spot for the first time, Kaytee’s 8-pound bag is a more manageable starting point than the 15-pound Audubon Park blend or Ernst Grain & Livestock’s 46-pound sack. It is intended for squirrels, rabbits, chipmunks, and other backyard animals, and the suggested outdoor use—scattering it in a designated area—makes the feeding plan straightforward. That approach may encourage small animals to forage away from bird feeders without requiring a special feeder.
The main limitation is a lack of ingredient detail in the product information: unlike Audubon Park’s corn, sunflower seed, and peanut blend, Kaytee’s mix is described as chunks without a specific ingredient list. That makes it harder to compare nutrition or know exactly what you are offering. Feeding wildlife can also increase animal activity in the yard. I’d pick this for a modest, low-commitment trial, not for buyers who need a fully specified blend or bulk supply.
Pros:- 8-pound bag is a more manageable starting quantity than the larger bulk options in this lineup.
- Intended for squirrels, rabbits, chipmunks, and other backyard wildlife.
- Can be scattered in a designated outdoor feeding area without a specialized feeder.
- A separate foraging spot may help draw small animals away from bird feeders.
Cons:- The provided product details do not specify the ingredient mix.
- Chunk form may not suit every feeder or preferred feeding setup.
- Feeding wildlife can increase animal activity around the yard.
Best for: New wildlife feeders who want a smaller bag to try a designated outdoor feeding area for squirrels, rabbits, and chipmunks.
Not ideal for: Buyers who want a disclosed ingredient list, a large-volume supply, or to limit wildlife activity around their property.
- Brand:Kaytee
- Weight:8 pounds
- Form:Chunk
- Container:Bag
- Target animals:Squirrels, rabbits, chipmunks, and other backyard wildlife
- Use:Outdoor
- Life stage:All life stages
- Feeding method:Scatter in a designated outdoor area
Our verdict“Pick Kaytee for a smaller first attempt at a separate wildlife feeding spot, but choose Audubon Park if a disclosed ingredient blend matters more.”
Ernst Grain & Livestock Non-GMO Bird and Wildlife Feed, 46 lb
A 46-pound bag makes Ernst Grain & Livestock the clear bulk pick for a property with frequent wildlife feeding or several feeding stations. Its blend of corn, barley, wheat, roasted soybeans, and black oil sunflower seeds is intended for a broad cast of visitors, including squirrels, birds, ducks, turkeys, rabbits, geese, and deer. Compared with the 15-pound Audubon Park food, this is much better suited to keeping multiple stations supplied—but that volume asks for substantial storage space and a steady use plan.
The mix can go in outdoor feeders or on the ground, giving buyers flexibility across a farm, large yard, or wildlife area. Its non-GMO designation is another point of distinction from products here that do not specify that feature. Still, it attracts far more than squirrels, so it is not a targeted squirrel-only solution. Choose this when broad wildlife appeal and fewer replenishment trips matter more than compact storage or control over which animals visit.
Pros:- 46-pound supply suits frequent feeding or multiple outdoor stations.
- Ingredient list includes corn, barley, wheat, roasted soybeans, and black oil sunflower seeds.
- Can be used in outdoor feeders or scattered on the ground.
- Non-GMO designation is specified in the product details.
Cons:- Large bag demands substantial storage space and may be excessive for occasional feeding.
- Broad target-animal list means it may attract deer and other wildlife in addition to squirrels.
- Outdoor wildlife feed is a poor match for buyers seeking a contained, bird-only feeding plan.
Best for: Landowners, farms, and caretakers running multiple outdoor feeding stations who can store and use a 46-pound bag.
Not ideal for: Small-yard birders seeking to redirect only squirrels, or anyone without room to store a large bag and accommodate varied wildlife.
- Brand:Ernst Grain & Livestock
- Weight:46 pounds
- Ingredients:Corn, barley, wheat, roasted soybeans, black oil sunflower seeds
- Special ingredient designation:Non-GMO
- Form:Granule
- Diet type:Plant-based
- Container:Bag
- Target animals:Birds, ducks, squirrels, turkeys, rabbits, geese, deer
Our verdict“Choose Ernst for high-volume, multi-species feeding on a property with storage space; choose Audubon Park for a smaller, more squirrel-focused supply.”
Lyric Fruit and Nut Wild Bird Seed Mix, 10 lb (2-Pack)
Fruit, nuts, sunflower kernels, pumpkin seeds, and corn make this the most bird-focused choice in this batch, with listed target species including cardinals, chickadees, grosbeaks, jays, nuthatches, titmice, waxwings, and woodpeckers. Squirrels may also be drawn to the nuts and seeds, but the product is designed for songbirds rather than as a dedicated squirrel diversion feed. That makes it a different choice from Audubon Park Squirrel & Critter Food, which is explicitly positioned for attracting squirrels and other wildlife.
The mix is made without fillers and works in hopper, covered tray, tube, and wire mesh feeders, so it offers more feeder flexibility than a product meant mainly for ground scattering. The two 5-pound bags also let buyers open one portion at a time. The tradeoff is that bird appeal remains the priority: squirrels may compete at the feeder rather than being redirected elsewhere, and the mix contains corn, which may not appeal to every bird. Pick it if birds come first and squirrels are welcome visitors, not if squirrel diversion is the main goal.
Pros:- Varied nuts, fruit, seeds, and corn target a broad selection of listed songbirds.
- No fillers are listed in the product description.
- Compatible with hopper, covered tray, tube, and wire mesh feeders.
- Two 5-pound bags allow the supply to be opened in portions.
Cons:- Designed as wild bird food, not a dedicated squirrel diversion blend.
- Squirrels may feed at the same bird feeder rather than being drawn to a separate spot.
- Contains corn, which may be less appealing to some birds.
Best for: Bird-focused households that welcome squirrels but want a varied fruit-and-nut blend for songbirds and several feeder styles.
Not ideal for: Buyers whose main goal is to pull squirrels away from bird feeders or who want a wildlife feed intended specifically for squirrels.
- Brand:Lyric
- Total weight:10 pounds
- Packaging:Two 5-pound bags
- Ingredients:Peanuts, almonds, pecans, cashews, pistachios, cranberries, raisins, sunflower kernels, pumpkin seeds, corn
- Form:Nuts, seeds, and fruit
- Diet type:Plant-based
- Feeder compatibility:Hopper, covered tray, tube, wire mesh
- Target species:Cardinals, chickadees, grosbeaks, jays, nuthatches, titmice, waxwings, woodpeckers
Our verdict“Choose Lyric when feeding songbirds is the priority and squirrels are acceptable visitors; choose Audubon Park when redirecting squirrels is the main objective.”
15 lb Raw In-Shell Peanuts for Squirrels, Birds & Wildlife – Grown in the USA
When a buyer wants a simple, recognizable food rather than a mixed wildlife blend, raw, unsalted in-shell peanuts give this pick a clear identity. The 15-pound bulk supply is intended for regular feeders, farms, and wildlife stations, and the listed visitors include squirrels, blue jays, woodpeckers, and other backyard wildlife. Compared with Audubon Park’s corn-and-sunflower blend, these peanuts offer a narrower ingredient choice; that can suit peanut-focused feeding, but provides less variety for animals that prefer a mixed ration.
In-shell format means squirrels and birds have to work through the shells, while the discarded shells can add cleanup around a feeder or feeding area. The unroasted, unsalted description and US origin may appeal to buyers seeking a minimally processed option, though the supplied specifications do not list a full ingredient panel or feeder compatibility. Choose this for a regular peanut-feeding station, not for tidy patios or anyone who wants a ready-to-eat, varied blend.
Pros:- Raw, unroasted, and unsalted peanuts offer a simple alternative to mixed blends.
- Listed as suitable for squirrels, blue jays, woodpeckers, and other wildlife.
- 15-pound supply suits regular feeding stations and farms.
- Product details state that the peanuts are grown in the USA.
Cons:- In-shell peanuts leave shells around feeders and take more effort to eat than shelled options.
- Single-food format offers less ingredient variety than the Audubon Park blend.
- The provided specifications do not list feeder compatibility.
Best for: Regular squirrel and wildlife feeders who prefer bulk, raw, unsalted in-shell peanuts for a dedicated outdoor feeding station.
Not ideal for: People feeding in tidy, high-traffic areas where shells create a mess, or buyers seeking a mixed feed or shelled peanuts.
- Weight:15 pounds
- Food:Raw in-shell peanuts
- Processing:Unroasted and unsalted
- Origin:USA
- Target animals:Squirrels, birds, and other wildlife
- Named target birds:Blue jays and woodpeckers
- Intended use:Regular feeders, farms, and wildlife stations
Our verdict“Pick these peanuts for a bulk, peanut-focused wildlife station if shell cleanup is acceptable; choose Audubon Park for a more varied blend.”
How We Picked
I compared these feeds by how clearly their ingredients and intended audience suit squirrel feeding, then weighed bag size, versatility, and the practical demands of storing and serving them. A focused peanut or squirrel-and-critter formula earns credit for making the feeding choice straightforward; a broad bird mix can still be a useful option when a buyer wants to attract several kinds of wildlife. I also treated large quantities as a benefit only for households likely to use them, since bulk feed calls for dry storage and a steady feeding routine.
The ranking favors options with a clear role and a manageable tradeoff, rather than treating the biggest bag or longest ingredient list as automatically better. Pennington leads for its focused shelled-peanut format, while Audubon Park and Kaytee Ultimate Backyard Wildlife Food have an advantage for buyers seeking wildlife-oriented blends. Bulk grain and mixed-feed options rank lower for a squirrel-specific goal because their larger quantities or wider appeal may not suit every yard. The product details provided do not establish nutritional analysis or sourcing beyond what is named, so I do not infer benefits that are not stated.
| bird seed for squirrel | Brand | Form | Target animals | Ingredients |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pennington Classic Shelled Pea | Pennington | — | — | — |
| CountryMax Cracked Corn Feed | — | Cracked corn | Chickens, turkeys, birds, deer, squirrels, and other wildlife | — |
| Lyric Wild Bird Mix with Corn | — | — | — | Cracked corn, white proso millet, shelled peanuts, safflower seeds, black striped sunflower seeds, black oil sunflower seeds |
| Kaytee Nut & Fruit Wild Bird S | Kaytee | Chunk | — | — |
| Sommer’s Critter Snack Wildlif | Sommer’s Wild Bird Food | — | Squirrels, chipmunks, rabbits, birds, and other critters | Corn, sunflower seeds, peanuts |
| Audubon Park Squirrel & Critte | Audubon Park | Seed | — | Corn, sunflower seed, peanuts |
| Kaytee Ultimate Backyard Wildl | Kaytee | Chunk | Squirrels, rabbits, chipmunks, and other backyard wildlife | — |
| Ernst Grain & Livestock Non-GM | Ernst Grain & Livestock | Granule | Birds, ducks, squirrels, turkeys, rabbits, geese, deer | Corn, barley, wheat, roasted soybeans, black oil sunflower seeds |
| Lyric Fruit and Nut Wild Bird | Lyric | Nuts, seeds, and fruit | — | Peanuts, almonds, pecans, cashews, pistachios, cranberries, raisins, sunflower kernels, pumpkin seeds, corn |
| 15 lb Raw In-Shell Peanuts for | — | — | Squirrels, birds, and other wildlife | — |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best Bird Seed For Squirrels
Choosing feed is only part of the decision: the right option also depends on what you want visiting your yard, how much you can store, and how you plan to serve it. These broader factors can help you avoid buying more feed or attracting more wildlife than you intended.
Decide Whether You Want Squirrels Only or Mixed Wildlife
A squirrel-labeled feed gives a clearer starting point if your aim is to feed squirrels rather than create a general wildlife station. A bird-and-wildlife mix may bring more variety, but the extra visitors can mean faster use and more competition around a feeder. Before choosing, decide whether a mixed yard is welcome or whether you want to keep the feeding area more focused. Product names can signal intended use, but they do not guarantee which animals will visit. Start with a small serving and watch what actually eats it. That gives you a better basis for changing the feed than assuming every ingredient will appeal to the same animals.
Choose Shelled or In-Shell Peanuts for Your Routine
Shelled peanuts remove the shell-handling step and may be simpler to portion, while in-shell peanuts provide a different feeding format that leaves shells behind. The choice is not just about convenience: shell debris can accumulate beneath a feeding spot, so think about where it will land and how you will clean it up. Avoid buying in-shell feed solely because it sounds more natural; choose it when the format works for your setup. If you are unsure how much your visitors will eat, a smaller bag can help you learn without storing a large supply. Keep any feed dry and use clean, dedicated containers for storage.
Match Bag Size to Consumption and Storage
Large bags can reduce repeat shopping, but they only make sense if you have a dry, protected place to store them and expect to use the contents regularly. A damp or poorly sealed storage area can undermine the benefit of buying in bulk. Smaller bags are easier to manage when you are trying a new ingredient or have limited storage, even if you need to replenish them sooner. Estimate how often you plan to feed rather than choosing by bag weight alone. If more than one household member handles feeding, agree on a portion routine so a large supply does not lead to excessive servings. Bulk grain feeds are especially worth matching to a predictable use pattern.
Treat Ingredient Variety as a Choice, Not an Automatic Upgrade
Blends with corn, nuts, sunflower seeds, or fruit can offer a varied feed, but a longer ingredient list does not automatically make a better squirrel-focused choice. Variety may also appeal to birds and other wildlife, which can change how quickly the bag is used and who gathers near the feeding area. If your priority is a simple, easy-to-understand feed, a single-ingredient option may be easier to manage. If variety is the goal, check the ingredient information on the package and consider whether the blend fits your local feeding plans. Do not assume that every mixed formula is interchangeable: ingredients and intended audiences differ between products. Begin with a modest amount before making a blend your regular choice.
Plan for Feeder Access, Cleanup, and Local Wildlife
Feed choice cannot fully control which animals reach a feeding spot; placement and access matter too. A ground-level serving area can leave more mess, while an accessible feeder may be visited by birds and other animals alongside squirrels. Choose a location where spilled feed and shells can be cleaned up without damaging a garden or attracting unwanted pests. Check local rules and wildlife guidance before establishing a regular feeding station, especially where feeding is restricted or can create conflict. Use portions that visitors finish rather than leaving feed out for long periods. A tidy routine often matters as much as the product when deciding whether squirrel feeding fits your yard.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a squirrel-labeled feed better than a bird seed mix for feeding squirrels?
A squirrel-labeled or squirrel-and-critter product is the more direct starting point when squirrels are your main target. A bird seed mix may still attract squirrels, particularly if it includes ingredients they will eat, but it is intended for a broader feeding purpose and may draw more kinds of visitors. Compare the listed ingredients and intended use rather than relying on the name alone. If you want to limit variety at the feeder, begin with a focused option and observe the result. If a mixed wildlife yard is welcome, a blend may better match that goal.
Should I choose shelled peanuts or raw in-shell peanuts?
Choose shelled peanuts if you want a simpler format to portion and would rather avoid shell debris. In-shell peanuts may suit a buyer who prefers that format and has a place where shells can be left without creating a cleanup problem. Neither format is automatically the right choice for every yard, so factor in storage, serving, and how much mess you are willing to manage. If you are new to feeding squirrels, a smaller quantity can help you learn how quickly it is used. Follow the package directions and keep the feed dry.
Is a 40- to 50-pound bag sensible for a backyard feeder?
A bag that large is sensible when you feed regularly, have adequate dry storage, and can use the feed at a steady pace. It may be an awkward choice for occasional feeding, limited storage, or a yard where you are still learning which ingredients visitors prefer. Large quantities also make a poor trial purchase if you are uncertain about the feed’s appeal. Consider how much you use over a normal week and whether the storage container can be sealed against moisture and pests. A smaller bag can be the more practical way to establish a routine.
Will these feeds attract birds as well as squirrels?
Some products are explicitly described as bird seed or bird-and-wildlife feed, so they are intended for a broader audience than squirrels alone. Squirrel and critter formulas are more directly positioned for wildlife feeding, though the product name does not guarantee which animals will visit your yard. The ingredients, feeder access, and location all affect who shows up. If you want to welcome birds too, a mixed formula may fit; if you prefer to focus on squirrels, choose a product with that stated purpose and monitor visitors. No feed can reliably control which local animals find an accessible food source.
How can I decide whether a mixed feed is worth choosing over a single-ingredient option?
Choose a mixed feed when ingredient variety and a broader range of visitors are part of the appeal. A single-ingredient feed, such as shelled peanuts, offers a more straightforward choice when you want fewer variables or want to see whether squirrels will eat a particular ingredient. Mixed feeds can be used up differently depending on which animals visit, so the remaining contents may not match what gets eaten first. Check the package details and begin with a limited amount before adopting a blend as your regular feed. The best fit is the one that suits your feeding goal, storage, and cleanup routine.
Conclusion
For most buyers seeking a clear squirrel-feeding choice, I recommend Pennington Classic Shelled Peanuts as the best overall, thanks to its focused ingredient and straightforward format. CountryMax Cracked Corn is the best value for frequent, high-volume feeding when you have dry storage and expect to use a large bag; occasional feeders should choose a smaller option instead. For a more purpose-made wildlife blend, Audubon Park Squirrel & Critter Food is my premium-style pick, while Kaytee Nut & Fruit Wild Bird Seed is the best starting point for beginners who want a smaller bag to try. Choose the raw in-shell peanuts for a specific peanut-in-shell format, or a Lyric mix if you want broader ingredient variety. My final rule: buy for the visitors you want, the quantity you can store, and the cleanup you are willing to handle.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
